Diviset SolutionsIndependent publishers · Edinburgh

Journal · Faith and family

Is it my fault my adult child left the Church?

Fr Charles Egbon, MSP ·

The short answer

Not necessarily, and rarely in the simple way you imagine. When an adult child leaves the Church, their own freedom is involved, and so is everything that shaped them as they grew: the people they met, and the questions or hurts they carried. Your example and upbringing mattered, as one influence among many. If you failed in real ways, bring that to Confession, then let God carry the rest and keep loving your child.

The box is at the back of the loft, behind the Christmas lights. He is looking for something else entirely. Inside, wrapped in tissue paper, he finds his daughter’s Confirmation candle, the wick still black where it was lit once and blown out.

He sits down on the boards and stays there longer than he means to. Leah is thirty-four now. She lives in Manchester and phones most Sundays, and she has not been to Mass in ten years.

Holding the candle, he starts going back through the years the way you go through a house looking for lost keys. The Sundays they missed Mass for her swimming galas. The night she asked him whether God was real, and he told her not to be silly because he was tired and did not know what to say. The two years he worked away and came home only at weekends. The arguments at the dinner table when she was sixteen, his voice rising, her chair scraping back. Each memory arrives like a piece of evidence.

His wife tells him they did their best. She means it kindly. It never reaches the place where the question lives.

So one evening after the weekday Mass, he waits until the church has emptied, and he asks.

“Father, is it my fault?”

I have heard that question in every parish I have served: in Nigeria, in Malawi, in London, and now in the Scottish Highlands. Mothers ask it more often. Fathers carry it too, usually in silence and often for longer. By the time they say it aloud, most of them have already found themselves guilty.

I usually begin by asking them to sit down.

Why the blame feels so certain

Sometimes guilt feels easier to carry than uncertainty. If it was my fault, then there must have been something I could have done differently, a lever somewhere in the past that I failed to pull.

The other possibility is much harder to accept: that an adult child, after everything you gave, can freely choose another way. No lever to pull. Just their freedom, and your love standing beside it with empty hands.

Your child’s faith belongs to your child

At your child’s baptism, the final blessing named you and your spouse “the first teachers of their child in the ways of faith.” First teachers. The word first leaves room for everyone who would teach them after you, and it leaves the ending with God.

Faith is a gift God offers to each person directly. You can prepare the ground, and you did.

The answer belongs to them.

In the parable Jesus told, the father hands his younger son his share and lets him go. He cannot make him stay, and he does not try. What he does is keep watching the road. When the son is still a long way off, it is the father who sees him first and runs.

That is the part of the story for you. Your child’s freedom was always their own. Your love can keep watching the road for as long as it takes.

One voice among many

When your son or daughter was seven, yours was the loudest voice in their life. By twenty it was one among hundreds.

Friends, lecturers, partners and colleagues all spoke into those years. So did a culture where hardly anyone mentions God in public, and where faith can look strange or simply irrelevant. Some young people meet unkindness from Christians. Some are wounded by scandal in the Church, and their anger at that is understandable. Many never make a decision at all. Life fills up, Sunday becomes the one free morning, and the years drift.

Your influence was real. It was also never the whole story.

When you know you got some things wrong

Every parent fails somewhere. It would be dishonest of me to tell you that nothing you did mattered.

Perhaps you were harsh about religion, or hypocritical. Perhaps faith in your house was all rules and no warmth, or your marriage broke in a way that shook your children’s trust in everything, God included. If something like that is true, name it.

There is a difference between responsibility and blame. Responsibility says, I did this, and I am sorry. Blame says, I am the reason my child is lost, and I always will be. The first leads somewhere. The second only goes round in circles.

Bring what is truly yours to Confession. God’s mercy reaches the past as well as the present. If it would help your child, tell them simply that you are sorry for a particular thing, and leave it there. An apology used as a way to get them back to Mass stops being an apology.

Then, having confessed it, put it down. God asks you to be faithful now, with the love you have today.

What to do when the guilt comes back

It will come back. Usually at night, or when a friend mentions that her son has started going to Mass again.

When it does, turn it into prayer. Say your child’s name to God and hand them over again. Guilt keeps your eyes on yourself. Prayer turns them back towards your child, and towards the God who loves them more than you can.

If you want to go further with that, I have written about how to pray for an adult child who has left the Church.

A prayer for a parent carrying guilt

Lord, You know what I did well and what I did badly.

I give You both.

Forgive what needs forgiving, and heal what I cannot reach.

Take my child into Your keeping,

and teach me to love them as they are today.

Amen.

Questions parents ask

Did I fail as a Catholic parent if my child left the Church?

Your task was to raise your child in the faith and to show them a Christian life as best you could. You may recognise things you would do differently today. But your adult child’s response to God belongs to them, and was never yours to control.

Should I apologise to my adult child for how I raised them in the faith?

If there is something specific you regret, a simple apology can heal a great deal. Keep it short and free of conditions, and leave Mass out of it. An apology that asks for something in return will be heard as pressure.

Does the Church teach that parents are responsible for their children’s salvation?

Parents are called to be the first teachers of faith, by word and by example. An adult’s response to God belongs to that adult. You are responsible for your own faithfulness, and the Church entrusts your child’s soul to the mercy of God.

What if my child says it is my fault?

Listen first, without defending yourself. There may be real hurt in what they say, and hearing it can open a door. Where they are right, own it. Where they are wrong, you can carry that quietly in prayer and leave the argument unwon.

What Remains by Fr Charles Egbon, MSP

Highland Faith Series · Book One

What Remains

Faith at the Edge of Scotland

Fr Charles Egbon, MSP, is Parish Priest of St John the Evangelist, Caol, and St Mary and St Finnan, Glenfinnan, in the Scottish Highlands. What Remains is written for parents and grandparents who keep praying for children who have left the Church.